Erie Insurance vs Nationwide
Side-by-side car insurance comparison based on rates across all available locations
Erie Insurance
4.7Avg Monthly
$88/mo
Best Rate
$71/mo
Best For
Claims service
Top Discount
Reduced usage 25%
Available In
8 locations
Nationwide
4.3Avg Monthly
$98/mo
Best Rate
$84/mo
Best For
Full coverage
Top Discount
SmartRide 40%
Founded
1926 · Columbus, Ohio
Available In
5 locations
Advertisement
Rate Comparison by State
Advertisement
Pros & Cons
Erie Insurance
Detailed profile not yet available for Erie Insurance.
Nationwide
Pros
- ✓SmartRide telematics can save up to 40% for safe drivers
- ✓Strong life insurance and financial services arm
- ✓Pet insurance available through Nationwide
- ✓Good multi-policy discount when bundling products
Cons
- ✗Not available in all 50 states for all products
- ✗Average rates are not always the most competitive
Which Should You Choose?
Erie Insurance is the cheaper option in 4 of 4 states where both insurers operate, saving an average of $20/month. Nationwide is cheaper in 0 states.
Erie Insurance has a higher average customer rating (4.7/5) compared to Nationwide (4.3/5). However, ratings can vary by state and coverage type.
Erie Insurance is generally best for claims service, while Nationwide stands out for full coverage. The right choice depends on your priorities — lowest price, best service, or specific discounts.
Advertisement