Are New-Customer Discounts Really Bigger?
We compared every welcome code reserved for new shoppers against the codes open to everyone, to see whether first-order offers actually run deeper β as of August 2026.
266 live verified codes analyzedThe Headline Numbers
Just 5% of the 266 live, verified codes in our database are reserved for new customers. Among offers expressed as a headline percentage, welcome codes carry a median of 10% off, against 15% for codes open to everyone β no welcome premium at all: codes open to everyone run 5 percentage points deeper, so loyalty often pays. Figures are drawn from the 11 new-customer and 170 everyday percentage codes live at the time of writing.
Welcome Offers vs Everyday Codes
Median headline percentage, side by side. Only percentage-type offers feed this comparison β fixed β$ offβ welcome offers and free-shipping deals are counted separately, since converting them to a percentage would mean assuming a cart size. A code stating a ceiling (βup to 30%β) is counted at that stated headline figure, so these are advertised rates rather than what a typical cart saves.
Welcome offers also lean toward round percentages and generic deals: of the 13 live new-customer codes, 11 are percentage offers, 0 are non-percentage deals, 2 are fixed β$ offβ, and 0 are free shipping.
Shop model cars β Diecast model cars from a direct distributor since 2001
Which Categories Reserve the Most Welcome Offers
Share of each categoryβs live codes that are gated to new customers, highest first. Categories with fewer than ten live codes are excluded so a thin sample canβt distort the ranking.
The Biggest Welcome Offers Right Now
The deepest live new-customer percentage code per retailer, at the time of writing.
Methodology
Every figure on this page is computed from our live coupon database β the same set of codes shown across the site β filtered to those marked verified and not yet expired, as of August 2026. A code is treated as new-customer-only when the retailer feed flags it as a first-order or new-customer offer. Nothing is modelled, estimated or seeded.
The welcome-versus-everyone comparison uses only percentage-type codes, where a headline figure can be read directly; fixed β$ offβ welcome offers, free shipping and other deals are counted in the type breakdown but excluded from the percentage medians, because converting them would require assuming a cart size. We report the median rather than the mean so a handful of unusually large offers canβt distort the gap. Figures change as codes are added, verified and expire, so please note the access date if you cite them. See also our US Discount Code Index for how deep discounts run overall, our Code Lifespan Report for how long they last, our free shipping index for how common free shipping is, and read about how we verify codes.
Put It to Use
First-Order Discount Codes
Browse the verified new-customer welcome codes behind this study
Discount Code Index
How deep US discounts run, by size, type and category
Code Lifespan Report
How much validity is left in live codes before they lapse
How to Stack Codes
Combine codes, cashback and loyalty for bigger savings